Here is my simple recipe for a DIY Coffee Creamer with vanilla. Coffee had always held a spot in my heart, until the last few years. Now I still enjoy a social coffee every so often and when I do, I love it with cream. While I can drink my coffee black for the sake of looking “cool” I prefer taking my coffee with creamer. No Shame here. Here is a quick and simple recipe for making your own DIY Vanilla Natural Bliss Coffee Creamer at home.

Honestly, though, I’m like a moderate creamer user. I like it light but still brown! Then there are other people I know who will literally pour the whole freaking bottle in a cup (exaggerating, obvi) Like would you like some coffee with your creamer?! 😂

But even living with a moderate amount of creamer in my life can get expensive, fast.

I liked the Natural Bliss coffee creamer that boasts having only 4 or 5 natural ingredients. Which I greatly appreciate. You may have noticed by now that it is really important that Artificial ingredients are not present in our lives anymore.

I spent nearly my entire pregnancy taking the time to analyze everything I consumed on a regular basis; from shampoo and deodorant to coffee and coffee creamer.

Did I mention I love flavored coffee creamer? I love that it can turn any cup of coffee into a mood, into a feeling. I love that. What I don’t love is paying $4.00 for a small bottle that only lasts me a week. We are on a single income in Southern California and although I do have more creature comforts than a lot of people around the world, I knew I needed to find a way to save some money.

DIY Coffee Creamer

By making my own DIY Vanilla Natural Bliss Coffee Creamer I have saved $4.00 a week – for 4 weeks – a total of $16 which bought me this pretty and amazingly scented candle from Homegoods! Yay

And it is so freaking simple. You only need 3 ingredients. You read that right. THREE.

DIY Coffee Creamer - This super simple, super fast DIY Coffee creamer will rock your mornings. Coffee-Mate Natural Bliss Copy Cat will save you tons of money and save your health too! - From https://goldengluegun.com
Coffee mate liquid creamer ingredient list

The regular Vanilla Coffee-mate has 13 and/or 14 Ingredients. LIKE WHAT??? Read for yourself.  What I want to know is… How is your body supposed to know what to do with all these chemicals?! Do you really think we can trick nature?! but I digress. Consuming ‘food’ products like this will lead to a multitude of health problems over time. We need to make smart, healthy choices now – while we still have the choice! A simple switch from chemical-filled creamer to a natural option saves money and improves health.

DIY Coffee Creamer

For DIY Coffee Creamer you will need:

1 cup Milk

1 – 14oz can of Sweetened Condensed Milk

2 teaspoons of Pure Vanilla Extract

Other supplies include:

  • A liquid measuring cup
  • Teaspoon
  • Funnel – so you don’t make a giant mess
  • Clean dry container to store your creamer in
  • Whisk or immersion blender

1 of 6

Start with 1 cup of Milk

First, you want to measure out your milk.


2 of 6

Mix in 1 can of S.C. milk

Add the sweetened condensed milk.


3 of 6

Mix it up

Then whisk together!


4 of 6

Add Vanilla

Then whisk in the vanilla.

DIY Coffee Creamer

5 of 6

Have a clean, empty bottle ready

The next step is to use a funnel and pour your freshly homemade coffee creamer in!

DIY Coffee Creamer

6 of 6

Shake up your DIY coffee creamer!

Give it a good shake and pop it in the fridge.

DIY Coffee Creamer

Enjoy a cup of coffee and feel good knowing you saved yourself some money and know you are drinking clean food by making your own DIY Vanilla Natural Bliss Coffee Creamer.

Nice work! We are amazing. Now go out and conquer!

So now it’s your turn! If you try this, tag me at @goldengluegun

Golden Gluegun is a DIY lifestyle blog featuring incredible DIY flips, sewing tutorials, crafts, and creative inspiration. Join me as we plan and create!

A simple switch from chemical-filled creamer to a natural option saves money and improves health. Try making this smart DIY coffee creamer!